Attitudes and Responses Toward the Poor Dbq

Attitudes And Responses Toward The Poor
During 1450 to 1700 half of Europe faced poverty. Eighty percent of a region faced possible starvation. Majority of the royal and wealthy people had negative attitudes toward the poor. Due to the fact that they believed the ???poor??? chose that lifestyle and did nothing to improve themselves. Several supporters of the ???poor??? had a positive attitude because they felt like helping those in need was the right thing to do. A lot of negative responses were taken against the poor. The royal, wealthy, particular town officials and citizens wanted those idleness people kicked out of the towns. While other town officials and supporters wanted the ???poor??? to receive a new opportunity and a place to stay.
To begin with, the first group included the documents written by members of a royal and or a wealthy family. This indicates that they do not have a very optimistic attitude toward the ???poor???. A negative attitude toward the ???poor??? is clearly established by Emperor Charles V, who states idleness is evil. Emperor Charles V considers this idea because he is a religious man and God is not fond of those who are unemployed and lazy (Doc 4). This is additionally shown with Jean Maillefer, a wealthy merchant, who believes the ???poor??? do not want to leave the life they are accustomed to. Jean Maillefer expresses this because he has heard the ???poor??? talk. With that he is certain they live a free life with no worries about anything that could happen (Doc 11). A response toward the ???poor??? is brought up by Cardinal Richelieu. Cardinal Richelieu believes that certain ???poor??? people who can work should. His views this because he thinks idleness people are taking away from the real ???poor??? and that??™s not correct (Doc 8). All of this clearly shows that the royal and wealthy did not want ???poor??? anywhere near them. They also thought the ???poor??? had an obligation of improving their lives.
Fallowing is Group 2, which consists of the town council and town citizens. A specific set of individuals support the ???poor???. A neutral attitude is shown by a Catholic priest who says you can??™t give the poor what you do not own because then it??™s not really giving. The Catholic priest says this because e is a religious man he knows that when you die you cannot take what you earned in this world. For when you go with God you??™ll have more riches than you could imagine. Therefore what good does it do to give away what is not yours anymore (Doc 1). A very positive attitude is taken by Vincent de Paul, Catholic Priest, who believed in giving to the poor. He believed this because he was a priest and priest should try to help anyone they see in need of a hand (Doc 10). A positive response is taken by a Town council in Dijon, France. They believed that they needed to give the ???poor??? a place to stay. They believed this because it would be incorrect for them to not help the ???poor??? who live in their town (Doc 2). A deleterious response to the ???poor??? is taken by a Town council in Rouen, France. The Town council who thought they should kick out of the towns the idlers not the ???poor???. The town council trusted this idea because no one wants to tolerate or even live in a town filled with good for nothing idlers (Doc 5). William Turner, an English doctor, assumed idlers or ???poor??? people had to intend to change their lives for the better. He accepted this truth because when people came to him for alms he for himself says how they did not care for their health. For they preferred to have alms than to be healthy and be able to support themselves or their families (Doc 6). It is noticeable that the citizens and the towns had two opposite views with what to do with the ???poor???. One thing was clear they both wanted to change them.
Next is Group 3, this group involves supporters and or helpers of the poor. They all believed in helping all of the ???poor???. Juan Luis Vives supposed the ???poor??? had no choice than to live the life they live. He believed this because when they lost everything they had they couldn??™t do anything about it and those people who had the obligation to help tem did not do it (Doc 3). The Poorhouse regulations thought rogue who said they were ???poor??? should be punished. They believed so because rogue said they were ???poor??? when in truth they really were not. They chose the lifestyle they have because they did not want o work and earn their living through sweat like any other men (Doc 7). Rembrandt van Rijn showed through his painting that you should always give the poor alms because they are in need. Anyone who is in need deserves all the help they can get (Doc 9). The supporters of the ???poor??? really thought everyone should help those in need. That way everyone in the town is working and having a good life. Instead of begging to be able to survive for at least one night.
In conclusion, Majority of the royal and wealthy people had negative attitudes toward the poor. Due to the fact that they believed the ???poor??? chose that lifestyle and did nothing to improve themselves. Several supporters of the ???poor??? had a positive attitude because they felt like helping those in need was the right thing to do. A lot of negative responses were taken against the poor. The royal, wealthy, particular town officials and citizens wanted those idleness people kicked out of the towns. While other town officials and supporters wanted the ???poor??? to receive a new opportunity and a place to stay. All of the documents prove that people had different views on how to think of the ???poor??? people. Most of the wealthy people who probably had no idea what it feels like to grow u in a poor family with barely any money thought the ???poor??? just need to get up and look fro a job. While others who were a little more understanding of them thought they needed help. A little push so they could earn a living and give both them and their families the opportunity for a better life. It all comes back to trying to change the ???poor???.

Do you like this text sample?
We can make your essay even better one!


order now
ˆ Back To Top
x

Hi!
I'm Samanta

Would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out